Data analysis
We check claims about railway safety against public data. Each analysis lists its sources and explains how the data were processed and what their limitations are.
-
16 November 2026
The origins of Spain’s AVE and the erosion of a promise of safety
With roots stretching back before 1992, Spanish high-speed rail has accumulated decades of experience, growth and regulatory development. The accidents at Adamuz and Urda demand scrutiny of maintenance, safety barriers and management: neither liberalisation nor increased traffic absolves the infrastructure manager of its duty to ensure safe operations. The AVE’s commercial success does not compensate for a failure of safety.
Our standards
- We only use data from public, identified sources, linked at the end of each analysis.
- We compare in relative terms (for example, per traffic or per kilometre) when absolute figures could be misleading.
- We explain what the data cannot show, and we never treat missing data as zero.
- If we find an error, we correct it and record the correction, with its date, in the analysis itself.